by Jeffrey Dale Starr
Humor is highly subjective. It's like saying "chocolate cake is delicious!" To a lot of people, maybe, but not to everyone. It's hard for me to believe that anyone would disagree with the choices on my list, but then again, there are so-called 'comedy classics' that I just don't get. Every few years I'll rewatch "Caddyshack" and stare at the screen (and I'm a golf nut!). Just isn't that funny to me. Same with "Animal House". I love Bill Murray and John Belushi. Those movies just don't make me laugh.
These, however, make me laugh my head off:

10. Airplane!
This movie should be named "1001 Cheap Gags", except there are a lot more than 1001 gags in it. I don't recall this method being applied before- just keep throwing out one joke after another and a few are bound to stick. Of course, quite a few of the jokes fall flat, but so what? Five seconds later you're gonna get another one.
Favorite bit:
"This woman is very sick, we have to get her to the hospital immediately."
"The hospital, what is it?"
"It's a big building full of patients but that's not important right now."

9. Napoleon Dynamite
Back to the chocolate cake analogy, this may be the most polarizing comedy in film history. The people that like it, love it. Those that don't are left scratching their heads. For me, it connects on a visceral level because I used to live in a small town in West Texas and I feel like I personally knew half the cast. I've rubbed shoulders with my own Napoleon, Pedro and Uncle Rico. Brrrrr.

8. Love And Death
For me, many Woody Allen movies could have made this list: "Take The Money And Run", "Bananas", "Broadway Danny Rose". But to me, "Love And Death" has the most quality jokes. To parody great Russian epics was a masterstroke...the overly earnest seriousness is an easy target. And he wore those anachronistic modern frames!
Favorite bit:
"You have such beautiful skin."
"I know...it covers my whole body."

7. Dumb And Dumber
The Farrelly Brothers are very funny. At times, though, they seem like 12-year-olds with no boundaries or sense of self-control. That's why I view "Dumb And Dumber" as the best of their films. There are a handful of gross-out jokes (Jeff Daniels in Lauren Holly's bathroom is the epitome of 'bathroom humor'). But there are also a lot of genuinely funny, and even sweet, moments. Which is why I also like the underappreciated "Kingpin".
Favorite bit:
"What's the soup of the day?"
"The soup du jour."
"Mmmm....sounds good. I'll have that."

6. The Freshman
On paper, this movie shouldn't work. Marlon Brando acting like Vito Corleone in a comedy? Sounds awful. Instead, it's one of the funniest movies ever made. The Matthew Broderick character, Clark Kellogg, reminds me a lot of Alan Arkin in "The In-Laws". He's just this regular guy dragged into a crazy situation with truly crazy people. With all the wonderful acting by Brando, Broderick and Bruno Kirby my favorite character is still the outrageous Maxmillian Schell as "Larry London". I've seen it 20 times and will happily watch it 20 times more.

5. Blazing Saddles
A lot of people would put this at the top of their list. I do think it's very, very funny. I just think "Young Frankenstein" is Mel Brooks' true masterpiece. But there are a bunch of great gags (and a bunch of clunkers- wouldn't be Mel Brooks otherwise). As usual, Madeline Kahn steals every scene she's in. Gene Wilder seems kind of subdued throughout, but does have my favorite bit in the movie: showing how calm his hand is, but then admitting that he shoots with shaky other hand. Also love Mongo punching the horse.

4. The In-Laws
What a glorious, unexpected gem this movie was when it came out. Back in the 1970s, a lot of movies seemed to just show up at the theater with no fanfare. Unfortunately, not a lot of people saw this movie in the theaters (even though my father and I passionately tried to get people to see it). Alan Arkin's deadpan genius was a great precursor to Tony Shaloub's Monk. As Peter Falk continues to drag Arkin into increasingly dangerous and bizarre situations, Arkin seems to get more blase and almost catatonic. Two words say it all - "Serpentine, Sheldon!"

3. Young Frankenstein
Mel Brooks has made some of the worst movies in history. He has also made a few of the funniest. Maybe because he was following the blueprint of "Son Of Frankenstein", he was unusually disciplined making "Young Frankenstein", and the result was his best film. Not only does it look beautiful, but has dozens of truly hilarious lines and scenes. I never get tired of it. If it's on TV, I'm watching it. Another clue to the unusually funny script: it has been rumored that Gene Wilder came up with some of the best bits.

2. The Big Lebowski
The most quotable movie of our generation. The Coen Brothers had an explosion of creativity with this one - fully realized characters spouting off one great line after another. The simple fact that The Dude, Walter and Donny would be pals is a hilarious foundation that allows the wonderful dialog to flow. "They're nihilists!" "You want a toe? I can get you a toe by 3:00. With nail polish." "You're out of your element, Donny!" On and on and on.

1. Monty Python And The Holy Grail
There will never be a funnier movie than "Monty Python And The Holy Grail". Ever. It's official. If you removed 90% of the funny things in this movie, I still might have it at the top of my list. Like all great art, it blows my mind to consider that one year this movie didn't exist, and then the next year it did. It may be a cliche for nerds to mention this movie, but try to view it with an open mind, pretend you've never heard of it. It's incredible. Just the killer rabbit scene alone is worth the price of admission. Favorite line: When accusing a woman of being a witch, the wise man asks what floats. Someone in the crowd yells, "Very small rocks!". Ahhhhhhh.
(Just missed the list: "Duck Soup", "Waiting For Guffman", "Nacho Libre", "Midnight Run").
Jeff Starr is San Francisco-based Impressionist oil painter who concentrates on themes of Japan, Dreams, Europe and California.

http://www.jeffreydalestarr.com/